NovelAI vs AI Dungeon: A Writing Suite or a Playable Adventure?
NovelAI is a prose tool that happens to run a text adventure; AI Dungeon is a game that happens to produce prose. Pick by what you actually want...
Most people don't leave OurDream AI over one thing. They leave over a specific annoyance โ memory, coin maths, blurred photos, no app. Here's the replacement that fixes each one, with prices.
OurDream AI is not a bad product. It sells unlimited roleplay and a serious media pipeline, and the price for what you get is defensible. But "defensible" is not the same as "right for you", and the complaints that push people out are usually narrow: the memory resets, the dreamcoins run out faster than expected, the images go blurry the moment a plan lapses, or the whole thing lives in a browser tab.
So this is not a ranked list of everything. It is a matching exercise. Find your complaint in the table, read the section for that pick, then check the caveats before you pay anything. OurDream's own flaws are covered in the OurDream AI review, and every score we publish moves as platforms change.
| Leaving because | Best pick | Price from | Free tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| Memory fades | Secrets AI | $9.17/month annual | 20 messages daily |
| Cheaper polished images | Candy.ai | $3.99/month annual | 5 messages total |
| Slow-burn relationship | Kupid AI | $13.99/month | Limited |
| Native phone app | Nomi | $15.99/month | Limited messages |
| No per-message pay | SpicyChat | Free ($5.95/month paid) | Yes, with queue |
| Story-first roleplay | Janitor AI | Free ($12.99/month Janitor+) | Yes |
| Budget unfiltered chat | CrushOn AI | $5.99/month | 100 credits monthly |
| Huge character choice | GirlfriendGPT | $15/month reported | Yes, limited |
| Game-like dating | DreamGF | $25.99/month | Minimal |
| Warm affectionate chat | Nectar AI | $9.99/month | 15 messages daily |
None of those prices are guesses. They come from pricing pages, published policies and third-party reviews where the vendor does not list a figure โ and I flag which is which as we go.
The homepage claims more than 11 million characters as of October 9, 2026. That is a lot of choice, and it is not why anyone cancels. The reasons cluster around money and access:
Account deletion, for what it is worth, takes 24 to 48 hours per the policy. Now the alternatives.
If your complaint is that the character forgets your name, your job or the thing you told it last week, Secrets AI is the closest thing to a fix on this list. It keeps images, video and voice in the product, so you are not trading media for memory.
Pricing: $19.99 monthly, or $109.99 yearly โ about $9.17 a month โ with 8,000 Moments. The Ultimate tier at $39.99 changes the media rates: 50 Moments per image, 600 for adult videos, and 50 per minute on voice calls. The free tier gives 20 messages a day with no media.
The catches are real. Moments do not roll over, so unused allowance evaporates monthly. Purchases are largely non-refundable and crypto is final. On privacy, data is encrypted with AES-256 at rest and chats are deleted when you delete your account โ but voice audio is not stored while chats may still be used to train models. We rate Secrets AI 9.9 overall, with memory at 9.9.
If you are weighing the two directly, the OurDream AI vs Secrets AI comparison goes line by line.
OurDream's media is good, but it is priced like a premium add-on. Candy.ai undercuts it badly on annual billing: $13.99 monthly, $8.99/month on quarterly, or $3.99/month annually ($47.88). You get 100 tokens a month, and tokens run about 4 per image. The interface comes in 13 languages, and it takes cards, Apple Pay, Google Pay and crypto.
Two warnings. First, the free tier is 5 messages โ total, not daily โ so you cannot evaluate it properly without paying. Second, the refund window is one day and capped at 20 tokens spent. Testers also report story threads resetting within days, which matters if memory is your actual complaint rather than a nice-to-have. Some guides still cite about $12.99/month; the pricing page is the authority.
We rate Candy.ai 9.8 overall and its images 10. The Candy.ai review covers the token drain in detail, and Candy AI vs OurDream AI is the head-to-head.
Kupid AI is the pick for people who want a companion that builds over weeks rather than a generator with a chat window. Reported pricing is $13.99 monthly or $84 yearly, with an Ultimate tier at $49/month and a $777 lifetime plan. Those figures come from a 2026 third-party review, not the official page โ so confirm them before you commit.
The lifetime option deserves a hard look. $777 ties a lot of money to a small vendor, and lifetime deals are only as good as the company's lifespan. We rate Kupid AI 9.3 overall and its memory 7.1.
Nomi is the straightforward answer to "why is this a website?". It has native iOS and Android apps, group chat, and pricing at $15.99 monthly or $99.99 yearly. The help wiki is explicit that it does not produce nude photos, though explicit text is allowed โ so if adult imagery is the point, this is the wrong door.
We rate Nomi โ overall, with UX at โ.
SpicyChat lets you chat free, with a queue. Paid tiers sit at $5.95, $19.95 and $29.95 monthly following a September 2026 price rise, and yearly billing is about 17% off. The platform claims 100 million registered users and runs its own SpicyXL model in-house.
Limits: no video, no iOS app (Android download is offered), and memory only grows on the higher tiers. We rate SpicyChat โ overall and value at โ.
Janitor AI is fully free for text, including JanitorLLM, and you can bring your own API key if you want a different model. Janitor+ launched in June 2026 at $12.99 monthly or $8.25/month yearly, and adds five times the context plus priority responses. The Discord community is close to 400,000 people.
What it does not do: image, video or voice generation of any kind. The API route also has a learning curve that casual users will resent. We rate Janitor AI โ overall. If you are choosing between the two big free-roleplay options, NovelAI vs AI Dungeon covers a different corner of that world.
Standard is $5.99 monthly or $4.90/month yearly, with 100 free message credits a month. You get 20+ models, memory up to 24K on top tiers, and an Unfiltered filter option.
The ladder is the problem. It reaches $199.99 monthly at the top end, free chat history is deleted after 7 days idle, and Trustpilot sat at 1.8 from 22 reviews as of October 10, 2026. We rate CrushOn AI 8.8 overall. For the softer comparison, see Janitor AI vs CrushOn AI.
GirlfriendGPT is the pick for sheer character volume. Plans are reported at $15, $35 and $50 monthly with 400, 1,200 and 2,000 coins; video runs about 20 coins; yearly is reported around $12/month. None of that is confirmed on an official pricing page, and there is no native mobile app. We rate GirlfriendGPT 8.9 overall.
DreamGF suits people who want game-like dating mechanics. The official price is $25.99 monthly with 100 tokens; an image is 10 tokens and a voice call is 7 per minute. The annual offer is $69.99 for the first year, then $311.88 โ an intro price that steps up hard. Guides cite a $15 to $30 monthly range, and billing is discreet. We rate DreamGF 9.1 overall.
Nectar AI is the warm, affectionate chat option: $9.99, $19.99 or $34.99 monthly, with a free tier of 15 messages and 10 generations daily, and a reported 50% off yearly. But it charges credits per message, and one reviewer estimated $60 to $75 a month extra for moderate use. We rate Nectar AI 9.6 overall and value at 8.6.
Beyond those: Nastia AI offers an uncensored free version per the company, and its $15.99 Unlimited plan lists unlimited messages, 4K selfies, voice messages, 1080p video and group chats up to 10 characters. Replika targets emotional support and wellness with native apps and voice calls, not NSFW media. Character AI has a huge community and native apps but blocks NSFW content outright. LusyChat self-reports image and video generation plus emotional continuity, with no independent confirmation. Yume AI is left out for lack of verified pricing and policy data.
| Platform | Monthly | Best long-term | Media payment |
|---|---|---|---|
| OurDream AI | $19.99 | $9.99/month ($119.88/year) | 1,000 dreamcoins monthly |
| Secrets AI | $19.99 | $9.17/month ($109.99/year) | 8,000 Moments monthly |
| Candy AI | $13.99 | $3.99/month ($47.88/year) | 100 tokens monthly |
| Kupid AI | $13.99 | $84/year reported | Not published |
| Nomi | $15.99 | $99.99/year | Credits |
| SpicyChat | $5.95 | About 17% off yearly | Tier unlocks |
| Janitor AI | Free / $12.99 | $8.25/month yearly | No media |
| CrushOn AI | $5.99 | $4.90/month yearly | Message credits |
| GirlfriendGPT | $15 reported | $12/month yearly reported | Coins |
| DreamGF | $25.99 | $69.99 first year, then $311.88 | 100 tokens monthly |
| Nectar AI | $9.99 | 50% off yearly reported | Credits |
The headline monthly price is rarely the bill. Work out the cost of a month of typical use โ messages, a handful of images, maybe a video โ before you decide a platform is cheap.
Every platform on this list meters media through coins, tokens or credits. If an ad implies otherwise, it is counting on you not reading the allowance. OurDream gives 1,000 dreamcoins monthly, roughly 200 images โ competitive, but videos at 100 coins per 5 seconds eat it fast. Candy.ai's 100 tokens at about 4 per image is roughly 25 images. Secrets' 8,000 Moments at 50 per image is 160 images on the base tier. Nomi does not do nude photos at all. Janitor AI does no media.
Memory is where the cheap apps quietly fail. Candy.ai's threads reportedly reset within days. SpicyChat only grows memory on higher tiers. CrushOn AI needs top tiers for 24K context. Secrets AI is the most explicit about remembering you, which is why it tops the memory row above. Nomi and Kupid AI are both built around continuity rather than one-off generation.
No app on this list has verified end-to-end encryption. OurDream's homepage claims it while its privacy policy describes server-side access, a moderation filter and model training. Candy.ai may also train on chats. Secrets AI encrypts at rest and deletes chats on account deletion, but voice audio handling and training permissions still apply. Treat every one of these as a service that can see what you type, use a separate email, and check how the charge appears on your statement.
OurDream remains decent value on media. Switch only for a clear reason: Secrets AI or Nomi for memory, Candy.ai for cheap annual images, SpicyChat or Janitor AI for free roleplay, CrushOn AI for budget unfiltered chat. If you want the wider field, the AI girlfriend reviews hub collects every app we have scored. Adults only, 18+.
Secrets AI fixes the memory problem while keeping images, video and voice, at $9.17/month on annual billing. If images matter more than memory, Candy.ai is cheaper on annual at $3.99/month.
Janitor AI is fully free for text, and SpicyChat is free with a queue. Neither matches OurDream's image and video generation, so you are trading media for zero cost.
OurDream, Candy.ai and Secrets AI are web apps you add to your home screen. Nomi and Replika have native iOS and Android apps, and SpicyChat offers an Android download.
They are not deleted, but they stay blurred until you resubscribe. Unused purchased dreamcoins remain on your account, limited to free features.
No. The homepage claims end-to-end encryption, but the privacy policy describes encryption at rest and in transit, a moderation filter, and permission to train models on chats.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls